The evidence suggesting that Brom Bones was the Headless Horseman in Washington Irving’s “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow” primarily stems from his character traits and actions throughout the story.
First, Brom is known as a prankster with a mischievous personality. He enjoys teasing Ichabod Crane, the protagonist, and often uses storytelling to instill fear among local townsfolk. This inclination for trickery positions him as a plausible candidate for assuming the identity of the Horseman.
Second, during a significant scene in the story, Brom is notably absent when Ichabod encounters the Headless Horseman. This absence is suspicious and leads readers to infer that he might be the one hiding behind the costume in pursuit of Ichabod, who is a rival for the affections of Katrina Van Tassel.
Additionally, at the end of the tale, when Ichabod disappears from Sleepy Hollow, Brom’s behavior changes. His laughter at Ichabod’s fate and the way he reacts to the situation suggest he may have orchestrated the whole event. The townspeople even note how he seems to take delight in the mysterious happenings surrounding Ichabod’s encounter with the Horseman.
Finally, Brom’s relationship with the legend of the Headless Horseman is reinforced by his knowledge of local folklore. He is well-acquainted with the story, which adds to the idea that he could mimic the Horseman and frighten Ichabod, ultimately aiding his own romantic pursuits.
In conclusion, while it’s never explicitly stated in the text, the combination of Brom’s character, his actions, and the narrative context provides compelling evidence to support the theory that he was, in fact, the Headless Horseman in this classic tale.